Turnbull wants to end the ‘Education
funding wars’.... well Abbott and Pyne started it when they first attacked Gonski
and then tried to nullify it going into an election by lying about supporting
it (a ‘unity ticket’ they said) and then backing or squirming out of it once in
power.
Turnbull took a hit on education at the last election and he’s trying to
do what Abbott did by hosing down the education sector with the aid of his old
debating pal David Gonski. I hope the AEU and ALP strategists are getting their
heads together around this because if they have any credibility at all they can
punch huge holes through this charade. I wonder if the privates and Catholic will kick up the stink against Turnbull and co. that they would have done if it was Labor?
'Gonski 2.0' review to
allocate resources as funding is cut to private schools
Government
announces 10-year plan to bring school funding to the same level for all
institutions, with David Gonski to lead second review
Read more
The first
thing to say is obvious. Voters care about two things: education and health.
The enduring
level of voter interest in these issues was underscored in the latest Guardian Essential
poll, which found a majority of voters wanted the government to use next week’s
budget to increase spending on healthcare (62%) and education (54%).
The next
thing to say is also obvious. The Turnbull government in its head, having
suffered the trauma of a near-death experience at the last federal election, is
still fighting the last war.
Having been
whacked comprehensively on health and education in 2016, carrying the last of
Tony Abbott’s heavy water, it wants the looming budget to mark a political
turning point of sorts.
It’s been
signalling for weeks that there will be some good news on Medicare next
Tuesday.
Then, on
education: rejoicing.
Courtesy of
the deck-clearing exercise over the past 48 hours, the government would dearly
like you to think that the cut could have been worse for universities,
(remember Tony’s mad deregulation idea – that was so much worse) and, oh
look – peace in our time on schools!
As is so
often the case with the Turnbull government, you really do have to mind the
whiplash.
After
arguing for many months the problems in Australian schools weren’t about money,
that money doesn’t automatically buy you quality, hey presto, apparently it is
about money, at least in part.
It was
unclear for much of the press conference on Tuesday why Gonski was there, to do
a new review, given the government had apparently accepted the principles of
his original school funding model.
Then it
became clear. Gonski would do a second review into improving the results of
Australian students.
So after a
long an arduous journey into hyper-partisan soundbite hell, the problem in
schools would be about money and about improving standards.
Voilà.
But lest
positive thoughts begin to settle on your brain, Labor was quick with some dark
side of the moon.
The shadow
education minister, Tanya Plibersek, said peace in our time was
actually a $22bn school funding cut dressed up as an improvement.
University fees: how much
more will you pay under the proposed changes?
This
interactive calculator estimates how the government’s proposed university
changes will increase your fees
Read more
“These
people think we are all idiots,” Plibersek thundered in some foliage in Sydney.
“We are supposed to be grateful that this isn’t a $30bn cut?”
The
government’s funding documents point out that the Coalition, with Gonski 2.0,
would spend $6.3bn less than Labor has pledged over the four years 2018 to
2021, and $22.3bn less over 10 years (2018 to 2027).
The
Victorian government says the new deal leaves it $630m worse off compared with
the original Gonski agreement.
The biggest
losers don’t stop with some pre-budget accounting wizardry.
Birmingham
noted rather delicately on Tuesday that as schools transitioned to a common
schooling resource standard, a “small number of schools will experience some
negative growth”.
In plain
English, this means some rich schools will lose funding – more than 300 on
current indications.
Many
ordinary voters will say bring it on, baby, this is a fight absolutely worth
having – but the various private education lobbies I suspect won’t be quite so
sanguine.
Catholic
education was none too pleased with the prevailing political winds on Tuesday.
So perhaps,
rather than Gonski 2.0, peace in our time – we have Gonski, round two.
From Katherine Murphy
in the Guardian
No comments:
Post a Comment